David Swanson is making much ado about a recent approval poll:
George W. Bush has set a record for unpopularity that may stand for all time: He now has a 19 percent approval rating. And, remember that Cheney has always polled LOWER than Bush. Imagine if the Democrats were to do something we care about (preserving the Constitution) by doing something they care about (winning elections) by forcing John McCain to choose between supporting impeachment and supporting these characters who may soon be less popular than the flu. Remember, Congress moved to impeach Nixon and STILL nobody liked him, but he was more pupular [sic] than Bush or Cheney: He stayed at around 25 percent through the process. Clinton climbed from about 60 to 65 percent as a reaction to Congress prying into his personal life and attacking him for a non-impeachable offense. Which scenario do YOU think is more like the current one, Clinton’s impeachment or Nixon’s? Truman’s popularity sank as Congress moved to impeach him too, but it never sank as low as Bush’s and Cheney’s… [emphasis added]
Inserted from <OpEdNews>
As much as I would love to gloat, honesty, combined with my background in market research demands that I point out that the basis for Swanson’s article is a flawed poll from American Research. Here are the questions, as asked:
Question Wording:
How do you rate the condition of the national economy these days – would you say it is excellent, very good, good, bad, very bad, or terrible?
Do you think the national economy is getting better, staying the same, or getting worse?
Would you say that the national economy is in a recession, or not?
A year from now, do you expect the national economy to be better than it is today, the same as it is today, or worse than it is today?
How do you rate the condition of the financial situation in your household – would you say it is excellent, very good, good, bad, very bad, or terrible?
Do you think the financial situation in your household is getting better, staying the same, or getting worse?
A year from now, do you expect the financial situation in your household to be better than it is today, the same as it is today, or worse than it is today?
Do you approve or disapprove of the way George W. Bush is handling his job as president?
Do you approve or disapprove of the way George W. Bush is handling the economy? [emphasis added]
Inserted from <American Research>
A perfunctory look at the questions reveals that they are not weighted in themselves. However the problem is in the order of question. The independent question of overall job approval should have been the first question asked, because the economy-centered dependent questions of the rest of the survey focus the respondents’ attention on that one issue. Once so focused, respondents are likely to answer the independent question on the basis of that one issue only. To be clear, I am not accusing American Research of rigging their poll. I cannot judge their intent in this. I’m merely pointing out why the poll is shoddy workmanship.
There is so much valid data about which to fault Bush and the GOP, we must be careful not rely on data so easy to refute.
Nevertheless, calling our Fanatic Failure “Mr. 19%” is great fun!
Cross posted from Politics Plus